| Award | Player | Team |
| Player of the Year | Matt Leinart | Indianapolis |
| Front Office Bowl MVP | Amos Hamrahi | San Francisco |
| Coach of the Year | Ben Burroughs | Indianapolis |
| Legend of the Game | Amos Hamrahi | San Francisco |
| Offensive Player of the Year | Matt Leinart | Indianapolis |
| Defensive Player of the Year | Leroy Hampton | Carolina |
| Offensive Rookie of the Year | Jack Davis | Green Bay |
| Defensive Rookie of the Year | Jared Kocher | Tampa Bay |
| All-League First Team Quarterback | Matt Leinart | Indianapolis |
| All-League First Team Running Back | Donald Brown | Indianapolis |
| All-League First Team Fullback | Tony Fiammetta | Cleveland |
| All-League First Team Tight End | John Carlson | Kansas City |
| All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Jon Szymanski | Philadelphia |
| All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Darrius Heyward-Bey | New Orleans |
| All-League First Team Center | Kennedy Gunja | Dallas |
| All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Al Whitfield | Oakland |
| All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Elbert Monroe | New York |
| All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Jeremy Hebert | San Francisco |
| All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Andy Pinkney | St. Louis |
| All-League First Team Punter | Robbie Mahoney | Tampa Bay |
| All-League First Team Kicker | Renaldo Curtis | Detroit |
| All-League First Team Defensive End | Nolan Jefferson | Los Angeles |
| All-League First Team Defensive End | Derrick Harvey | San Francisco |
| All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Clifton Hardy | New England |
| All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Jason Shirley | San Francisco |
| All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Terry Danskin | Jacksonville |
| All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Donnell Holliday | Carolina |
| All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Richie Flores | San Diego |
| All-League First Team Cornerback | Bennie Holbrook | Detroit |
| All-League First Team Cornerback | Doug Word | Pittsburgh |
| All-League First Team Safety | Leroy Hampton | Carolina |
| All-League First Team Safety | Graham Mayo | Seattle |
| All-League Second Team Quarterback | Ralph Horton | Pittsburgh |
| All-League Second Team Running Back | Cam Chase | Oakland |
| All-League Second Team Fullback | Leroy Hartman | New York |
| All-League Second Team Tight End | Timothy Antonio | San Diego |
| All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Melvin Rivera | Indianapolis |
| All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Lance Vazquez | Tennessee |
| All-League Second Team Center | Alex Mack | Indianapolis |
| All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Marshall Brooks | Cincinnati |
| All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Irv Strong | Green Bay |
| All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Zach Snellings | Pittsburgh |
| All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Jacques Beaton | Dallas |
| All-League Second Team Punter | Paul Robertson | New York |
| All-League Second Team Kicker | Ethan Malone | Tampa Bay |
| All-League Second Team Defensive End | B.J. Raji | St. Louis |
| All-League Second Team Defensive End | Jamie Crowell | Miami |
| All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Chris Bosworth | Houston |
| All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Sedrick Ellis | Green Bay |
| All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Jason Reynolds | Pittsburgh |
| All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Craig Meyer | Chicago |
| All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Jessie Gehrig | Denver |
| All-League Second Team Cornerback | Jamie Ahlstrom | St. Louis |
| All-League Second Team Cornerback | Fernando Harris | Detroit |
| All-League Second Team Safety | Jamie Denyer | Los Angeles |
| All-League Second Team Safety | Michael Mitchell | Denver |
| League's Fastest Man | Jon Szymanski | Philadelphia |
| League's Strongest Man | Phillip McCleary | Oakland |